Design Build Construction vs General Construction: A 2023 Guide
General Construction vs Design Build Construction:
Do you ever wonder how a vacant plot of the ground came to hold a complete building when you saw a retail center, hospital, or school?
Everyday structures that we see have a complex construction process going on behind the scenes. It starts with design, then bidding, and finally building.
This procedure takes place in a variety of ways. For example, the Design and Build method is popular along with the conventional approach.
Project owners seek to experiment with novel methods of planning, designing, and constructing their projects. This surges the number of design build constracts with time.
Like traditional or general construction, design build construction has merits and demerits. The situation at hand will be the deciding factor as to if traditional or design build construction is needed.
In this blog, we will differentiate between general construction and design build construction, discussing their elements, merits, and demerits. Without any further ado, let’s begin.
General Construction: An Introduction
It makes sense that we first understand what a general construction is and then gradually move towards design build construction.
There are three stages in general to the traditional method.
The traditional approach starts with design. Before any construction is done, the client collaborates with a firm that specializes in architectural design to lay out the building design. The designers are not involved in any aspects of the construction process other than those that relate to the design. This is in contrast to a design-and-build agreement.
Traditional contracts set apart the organizations in charge of the various project components. They move on to the bidding phase once a design is over and the project owner authorizes it.
As part of this phase, the client will receive proposals from a number of outside contractors depending on the finished design. In addition, the client must approve all the project specifics, including the construction expenses, in the proposals.
Following the project owner’s selection of their construction team, the various design and building organizations work together to execute the plans. The traditional approach organizes the project’s steps by dividing the groups in charge of each construction component.
Design Build Construction: An Introduction
One team completes the entire building process, from planning to building, under design build construction, a contemporary approach in the construction business.
Clients no longer need to collaborate with different architectural design teams to create floor plans, as was the case with general contracts.
The design build contract aims at streamlining project collaboration and communication for both the client and the construction crew.
As the project progresses, designing and building are frequently done concurrently. Therefore working with only one team may result in greater communication than working with different entities.
By selecting the complete project team prior to the commencement of the project, this strategy also streamlines the bidding procedure. In addition, the project owner will only need to deal with one person for all of their design and construction requirements, giving them greater control over project oversight.
Difference Between General Construction and Design Build Construction
The following are the main points of difference between the traditional or general construction and design build construction.
|Factor||General Construction||Design Build Construction|
|Time||Design and construction are sequential here, increasing project schedules||Construction overlaps design and reduces project schedules|
|Communication||Multiple communication channels||Single point of contact throughout the project|
|Cost||Initially unknown. Certain at a later stage||Costs are realized and fixed from initial design phase|
|Value Engineering||Occurs when you hire a firm||Occurs at the project onset|
|Risk||Risk of failure to perform by consultants or contractors remains with the client||With a single, united workforce, reduced risk and liability|
|Control||Owner retains authority over construction design and planning.||Less owner knowledge and resources are needed|
|Flexibility||Contract-heavy with little room for client-side modifications. Projects may take longer to complete, schedules and programs may alter, and costs may increase.||Client-side variants can be modified quickly and nimbly. Costs and designs are produced simultaneously.|
Essential Elements of a Design Build Construction
For a design build construction project to commence, there are three documents that one will require. Here they are:
The project owner outlines all of their needs for the project in this component. Even though the team will handle the design, the employer will still need to provide their expectations for the contractor to use as a benchmark when creating their proposal and quotation. It is because the contractor bases their work on what the customer anticipates seeing after the project is finished.
Any other documents that can aid the contractor in understanding the project, such as those relating to the soil study report, the local sewage system, and land ownership laws, may also be required by the employer.
Proposal by Contractor
The contractor will submit the project owner a proposal that includes a complete project breakdown based on the employer’s requirements. In order to meet the needs of the project owner, the design-build team specifies the scope of the design proposal, the materials required, the estimated time of completion of construction, the site layout, and other contract-specific details.
The contractor’s proposal is sent to the customer for approval and includes names, contacts, and pertinent information for contact tracing.
Contract Cost Assessment
The estimated project cost is shown in the Contract Sum Analysis, which is provided to the client for review. This document includes a complete description of every component’s cost and the project’s anticipated total cost.
Based on the study of the contract cost in relation to their budget at this point, the client may make changes. Following approval, billing arrangements and interim payments will be discussed between the project owner’s team and the contractor’s team.
Essential Elements of General Construction
The general construction route is a bit different, and is more popularly known as “Design, Bid, Build”. The following are the crucial elements of general construction.
The project owner lays down the building design in collaboration with an architectural design company, providing the requirements and the final appearance of the overall structure. The budget, timetables, and implementation planning happen during the design phase.
Independent contractors compete for the chance to take on the project, presenting offers to the client, who will use them to decide which company to hire. In addition, the organization must provide a comprehensive list of all needs, costs, timelines, and other information because contractors normally compete in a single stage.
The hiring of a contractor initiates the building phase of the project. It is during the building stage that the structure actually begins to take shape physically.
The project should go without interruption during construction, even though elements and designs may alter.
Benefits and Limitations of Design Build Construction
The following are some note-worthy benefits of design build construction for every project owner.
Better communication with low risk
This approach simplifies the owner’s management of risk by cutting down the number of contact points. As the primary point of contact and responsibility, the design-builder is now the only party to contact. The project owner avoids the risk of having to sue numerous people or of being unable to pinpoint the responsible party for a specific flaw or error. Nevertheless, it emphasizes the project owner’s potential remedies because only one party may be liable.
By merging the design and construction parts of a project, this tactic reduces the delivery date. Because of this, the design of the building can be developed gradually as the building process advances. However, since the project owner is pressed for time, it is appropriate in those situations.
The project owner will save money by utilizing this strategy. When a person employes a single company, there are fewer overhead costs to bear, more straightforward and fewer managerial and legal tasks to complete, a more negligible risk of a lawsuit, and fewer parties to deal with.
Creativity and a holistic construction approach
This strategy encourages the design-builder to use the most creative and economical methods to organize and construct the building. Only because the project team meets early on to address potential issues that might later arise, including the designer and the contractor, is it even conceivable. Furthermore, it lessens the likelihood of design faults, which are more difficult and expensive to correct. Additionally, the person can modify the design to match the conditions of the actual site since one person is both the designer and the contractor.
With benefits, there exists some limitations too, for anything, and here they are for design build construction type.
Might not produce the expected result
Because there is no established design to use as a starting point, the project will likely not deliver the anticipated results. After all, both the design and construction processes are ongoing at the same time. As a result, the finished product might not be what the project owner intended, particularly if the employer’s requirements and the contractor’s proposal are not thorough enough to guarantee that the project owner and design-builder are on the same page.
Lack of experience
Because the company must show expertise in both designing and building, rather than just one of them, the design-competence builder’s level may also be affected. For instance, this can be very challenging when the project requires incredibly elaborate designs. Assume, for example, that a design-builder primarily focuses on construction rather than design. If that happens, they might be unable to create more complex designs or push themselves as far as possible with the project’s design. The design-builder does, however, occasionally subcontract out particular tasks. For example, the design-builder, primarily a contractor, could hire a designer as a subcontractor or hire one to assist them with the process.
Quality Problems for the Project Owner
A further potential effect of the Design and Build technique is that the project owner may experience poor quality in the final output. The designer, who frequently stands in for different viewpoints from the contractor during the construction process, typically interprets the project owner’s vision through the design. For instance, when the designer and builder are the same people, the architect’s concept could be biased in favor of the contractor because the two roles are no longer in balance. On the other hand, if the project owner lacks the technical expertise to oversee, they might be able to manage this if they hire a consultant or agency to help.
Benefits and Limitations of General Construction
Here are some key benefits of general construction type.
The project owner can be more confident in the costs and successful completion of the project because the design, budget, and project specifics are established in advance. The traditional method offers a solid foundation for all stakeholders in the project to follow, but the design-and-build process may lead to unanticipated modifications midway through the project.
Organizing Individual Entities
The client may be guaranteed the degree of competence for each entity by keeping them distinct, so they can concentrate on their areas of expertise rather than trying to be experts in all things by having everyone under one roof.
Next, we have two key limitations of general construction method.
Comparing the old process to the design-and-build method, flexibility after the tender is more challenging. It ‘s difficult to modify once the building and construction starts because every part of the project review and acceptance is done. During the planning phase, the customer must communicate any adjustments they have in mind.
In any other case, the project owner may consult with the parties concerned regarding any adjustments midway and provide legal documents to support those changes.
The various entities might or might not collaborate in the conventional fashion. Therefore, a collaboration between the different stakeholders could be complex, especially if their beliefs and methods are at odds.
The project owner must choose partners with the best potential for cooperation, given how they operate.
What to Do Next?
Once you select the method you will opt for, be it design build construction or general construction, you then proceed towards partnering up with the right people who do the job, meet your needs to the T and prevent any hassle.
Apart from the construction phase, you must also complete a home foundation inspection. Because while you get the house built, it might be great, but with time, the interiors and exteriors may receive damage, and if you don’t get an inspection and repair done in time, you can face severe consequences, which a home foundation inspection could prevent.
If you live in Miami-Dade county, Broward county, or anywhere in Florida, you must get 40-year recertification per the laws. 40-year recertification will ensure your property is safe and does not indicate any signs of damage for the next few years. You must get your property repaired before it becomes the next headline of a horrific collapse.
The End result?
Their properties were safe from receiving significant damages, and the property life wen up too.
So, here was an in-depth differentiation between a general construction and a design build construction process.
Not just that.
Going through a specific process and getting your house built is not the last thing you’ll have to do.
You must take up inspections and repairs seriously, get in touch with professionals, and be ready for it even if you have to do it in the future and not now.
Planning leads to preventing devastating incidents. That’s what you must do.
Souffront Construction and Engineering ranks in the top 5 construction and engineering firms, especially for design build construction and 40 year recertification.
We are a team of expert general contractors, level II certified thermography inspectors, and structural engineers with a mission to construct top-quality properties and provide professional inspection service to prevent any property from even minor damage. Feel free to contact us to learn more about our services and how we can be the ideal pick for you regarding construction and inspection.
John Souffront is a seasoned leader in the construction and engineering industry, with over a decade of experience at the helm of Souffront Construction & Engineering. Known for his unwavering commitment to excellence and innovation, John has propelled his firm to the forefront of the field, delivering cutting-edge solutions for complex projects around the country.